What does the pomegranate scene symbolize in Amir's attempt at penance?

• A. It foreshadows Hassan's eventual forgiveness.
• B. Hassan's physical strength
• C. Amir hopes Hassan will hurt him to absolve his guilt
• D. The end of childhood

Answer: (C)

The scene is testing how atonement is understood by Amir. He believes that real penance can come only through some form of punishment or pain inflicted on him, not through confessing, taking responsibility, or making genuine restitution. The pomegranate becomes a tool he uses to try to force that punishment: he asks Hassan to hurt him so the guilt he feels might be washed away by the suffering, even if only temporarily.

This moment shows Amir’s flawed idea of redemption—he wants the other person to bear the burden of his guilt, rather than facing the truth himself. Hassan’s response reinforces the point that true accountability isn’t achieved by pain or coercion; it requires honesty and real action to repair the harm. The other options don’t capture the motive at play: it’s not about Hassan’s forgiveness, Hassan’s physical strength, or simply the end of childhood, but about Amir seeking punishment as a path to absolution.